A More Detailed Look at Our Case Against General Motors
Posted by shark
This an an excerpt from the document, “Memorandum Opinion Enforcing Provisions of Sale Order With Respect to the Moore, Et Al. Plaintiffs”.
This dispute involves allegedly contaminated groundwater that migrated from property previously owned until July 2009 by General Motors (“Old GM”) and now owned by General Motors LLC (“New GM”) into the water wells of nearby properties that were used by homeowners for drinking water and other normal household uses. The alleged contaminant is sodium chloride (“road salt”), allegedly used in excessive quantities by Old GM and then by New GM to treat the roads on the Milford Proving Grounds (“MPG”) in Michigan during winter months. The plaintiffs in an action pending in U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan allege that the contaminated groundwater caused personal injury and property damages. New GM asks this Court to enforce the Sale Order entered by the bankruptcy court to accomplish the bankruptcy sale of most of Old GM assets, including the MPG, to New GM, and to enjoin the plaintiffs from proceeding with some but not all of the claims asserted in the pending action.
New GM acknowledged during argument that it assumed liability for any required environmental response costs, whether Old GM or New GM contaminated the groundwater, although, at this stage at least, no government agencies charged with enforcing environmental laws has required remediation.
The Court concludes below that many but not all of plaintiffs’ claims may be asserted against New GM, some because they raise claims for which New GM contractually assumed liability and other because the claims may be asserted against New GM based on its own conduct.
Complicating matters, the plain language of the Sale Order and Sale Agreement are not a model of clarity regarding the contours of New Gm’s liability for common law claims for personal injury and property damage due to environmental contamination.
Judge Gerber previously construed the provisions of the Sale Order and Sale Agreement concerning environmental law in In re Gen. Motors Corp.
In the Sale Decision Judge Gerber interpreted the environmental provisions of the Sale Agreement to require New GM to comply with the Environmental Laws relating to the Transferred Real Property.
New GM did not assume liability for claims relating to the property based on Old GM’s conduct. Accordingly, the Court holds that the Moore Plaintiffs are precluded from proceeding with their common law claims against New GM related to Old GM’s conduct (Counts III through VII).
As explained below, the Court concludes as follows:
- Plaintiffs may not assert common law claims against New GM for personal injury or property damage based on groundwater contamination that migrated from the MPG before the sale of the Property to New GM was completed.
- For personal injury or property damage claims based on groundwater contamination from Old GM’s dumping of road salt before the Property sale to New GM, but which migrated from the Property after the Property was owned by New GM, the Sale Order does not bar such claims.
- In addition, the Moore Plaintiffs are permitted to proceed with their common law claims against New GM related to New GM’s conduct. However, the Moore Plaintiffs must remove their claim for exemplary damages based on conduct of Old GM.
Don’t forget to check out our feature on Jalopnik.com for a more detailed look at this case, including interviews with the plaintiffs and our head attorney, Mr. Alexander McH. Memmen.
View our previous blog post, Uber Changes Legal Process for Sexual Assault Victims
June 27, 2018
While the United States-Mexico border might be thousands of miles from Chicago, the topic of immigration is one that hits close to home for Chicagoans. Last week, news broke that families were being separated at the Southern border. Children as...
June 14, 2018
Chicago is no stranger to test piloting new convenience based start-up companies. From being one of the first cities to use food delivery services like Grubhub and 24/7 laundry lockers like Pressbox, Chicagoans have shown huge interest in these new...
June 6, 2018
A recent decision by the Supreme Court means that sports fans will now have more opportunities to place legal bets on sports teams. On Monday, the Supreme Court voted 6-3 to end a 1992 law that deemed sports betting illegal...
May 17, 2018
This an an excerpt from the document, "Memorandum Opinion Enforcing Provisions of Sale Order With Respect to the Moore, Et Al. Plaintiffs". This dispute involves allegedly contaminated groundwater that migrated from property previously owned until July 2009 by General Motors...
May 16, 2018
Uber has announced its plans to change the legal process for sexual assault victims involving employees, drivers, and other riders. Before Tuesday, anybody that alleged sexual assault involving somebody related to Uber, were subject to a lengthy legal process. CNN...
May 8, 2018
Check out our recent mention in an article about a case we've taken on against General Motors. Click this link to read the full story.
May 8, 2018
Today, virtually everybody has an online presence. From Facebook, to Twitter, to Snapchat, social media has become a core part of our lives. People can use these platforms to document every second of their life, from who they’re with, to...
May 1, 2018
Uninsured motorists are more common than you think. According to a 2016 study, 13.7% of Illinois drivers, or about 1 in 8, were uninsured, ranking the state 18th for most uninsured motorists. Not only are uninsured motorists a threat to...
April 24, 2018
Office workers are exposed to more hazards than one might think. Workplace hazards come in many forms including slip-and-fall accidents, ergonomic hazards, poor indoor air quality, electrical fires, as well as many other dangers. It was reported in 2016 that...
April 18, 2018
Intense work load in the office can lead to distraction in your personal life. Often, when the workplace demands attention outside of work hours, this can take shape in the form of distracted driving. Employees can frequently find themselves using...